There is something undeniably weird about the new Kirk that weā€™re seeing in Strange New Worlds. He doesnā€™t yet ā€œfeelā€ intuitively like Kirk to me, especially in the rom-com episode. But I do think his writing and, to a lesser extent, his performance show that the writers are thinking deeply about the character and what people have been missing about him. In a sense, SNW may be trying to counteract the phenomenon of Kirk drift, where pop culture stereotypes about the characterā€™s impulsive, womanizing ways makes it impossible to understand the person we actually see on screen.

What the first season finale shows us is a Kirk who is by the book, yet decisive and sure of himself. He does not disobey Pike, but he is not afraid to tell him heā€™s wrong ā€“ not based on gut feelings, but based on a sound tactical analysis that proves to be right. Compared to Picard, Kirk ā€“ especially the movie Kirk ā€“ may seem brash and prone to violate the rules, but TOS consistently shows us a captain who respects authority but is willing to push it up to the very limit to protect his crew and achieve his goals. Itā€™s interesting that the episode picks up on this aspect of the character as the one that creates an instant bond with Spock. Itā€™s not his emotional nature or his instincts or whatever else, itā€™s his respectful yet firm leadership style ā€“ a sharp contrast to Pikeā€™s tendency to leave his subordinates to their own devices.

In the romcom episode, the message is a little garbled by the fact that this is an alternate timeline Kirk, but I think it highlights the fact that (a) Kirk is not a compulsive womanizer by any means and (b) Kirk bonds sincerely with women who feel isolated by leadership or other burdens ā€“ not in a predatory way, but in an empathetic way. In contrast to Chris Pineā€™s layabout troublemaker who is constantly getting laid (at least in the first film), the Kirk from TOS is basically a lonely nerd. A charismatic one, to be sure, but still a lonely nerd. Even well into his second command, heā€™s haunted by the guy who bullied him at the Academy! He is, if anything, sexually thwarted by his sense of duty and his ā€œmarriageā€ to the ship. Hence when he meets a woman with a similar predicament, they are drawn to each other. Everyone has a type! Itā€™s just a sad coincidence that he wound up meeting someone of his type virtually every episode in season 3.

I donā€™t think itā€™s perfectly executed, at least in the pairing with Laā€™an, but I do like that theyā€™re trying to refresh our perspective on the character and that theyā€™re doing it in a way that reminds us of all the traits from TOS that the pop culture parody of ā€œCaptain Kirkā€ leaves out. But what do you think?

  • erbazzone@startrek.website
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    arrow-down
    1
    Ā·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Sorry if Iā€™m just maybe brutal but I still think and at this point I will ever think that itā€™s one of the worst recast Iā€™ve seen. Pike is more Kirk than Kirk. As Iā€™ve read somewhere SNW Pike is like Kirk and SNW Kirk is like Pike.