Keep reaching for further and further strawmen. Democracy requires majorities of people to do anything. A few people voting for nonsense options doesnt do anything. A few people murdering actually kills people. If youre worried a majority of people will choose a nonsense option, well then you dont believe in democracy anymore.
Itās not a strawman. You think a minimum age is āpointlessā because āno one would actually vote for a childā. I transplanted that exact argument into a situation I knew would showcase its absurdity.
Proving you wrong isnāt a fallacy!
Democracy requires majorities of people to do anything.
Majorities can be misled. Surely youāre aware of this?
A few people voting for nonsense options doesnt do anything.
Itās not āa few peopleā though. Trump is actively and increasingly popular despite his obvious crimes.
A few people murdering actually kills people.
A bloc of fanatics actually gets their way when organised. Thatās democracy.
If youre worried a majority of people will choose a nonsense option, well then you dont believe in democracy anymore.
Now thatās a fallacy - A false dichotomy, AKA a black and white fallacy.
You sure changed your tune quick! What happened to this not being likely? What happened to it being pointless to block voting for criminals because they simply wouldnāt be that silly?
I believe in democracy. But I also believe in education - and you guys over there in the US arenāt good at either of those things. You have a corrupt, shambolic democracy and a failing education system that churns out dumb, blind followers to feed it.
This is extremely naive. In the same vein, I suppose thereās no point in keeping murder illegal, since people should just know not to do that.
Keep reaching for further and further strawmen. Democracy requires majorities of people to do anything. A few people voting for nonsense options doesnt do anything. A few people murdering actually kills people. If youre worried a majority of people will choose a nonsense option, well then you dont believe in democracy anymore.
Itās not a strawman. You think a minimum age is āpointlessā because āno one would actually vote for a childā. I transplanted that exact argument into a situation I knew would showcase its absurdity.
Proving you wrong isnāt a fallacy!
Majorities can be misled. Surely youāre aware of this?
Itās not āa few peopleā though. Trump is actively and increasingly popular despite his obvious crimes.
A bloc of fanatics actually gets their way when organised. Thatās democracy.
Now thatās a fallacy - A false dichotomy, AKA a black and white fallacy.
According to you, there are only two options:
I believe people only ever vote rationally.
I donāt believe in democracy.
This is absurd.
You dont believe in democracy. Democracy is people collectively deciding, and you dont like what people are collectively deciding.
You sure changed your tune quick! What happened to this not being likely? What happened to it being pointless to block voting for criminals because they simply wouldnāt be that silly?
I believe in democracy. But I also believe in education - and you guys over there in the US arenāt good at either of those things. You have a corrupt, shambolic democracy and a failing education system that churns out dumb, blind followers to feed it.
US voters are too dumb to be trusted with having democracy then.
Sounds to me like you are the one who doesnāt believe in democracyā¦ because thatās not my take.